I think the point of the thread is to highlight the issues of a) people posting a sample workbook with (maybe) a comment that the question, etc., is in the workbook., and b) those who respond to a thread in a similar vein, perhaps in retaliation. That is, just a workbook, no commentary.

Personally, I try to include a level of detail in the post and supplement it, where necessary, with an updated sample workbook.

I guess, like most things, we have different viewpoints.

If I can say something simple like "put this formula in cell C2 and copy it down", I probably wouldn't bother with a workbook. If it's got a complex formula, maybe Regional Setting issues, or some long winded code, I almost certainly would.