VBA CountIf logic checking Text Box Input

Hi Everyone,

I've gone back and cleaned up my code and tried declaring my "EvalNotScored" variable as a range, but to no avail. If anyone has any further suggestions on how to develop a functioning CountIf statement inside of VBA, I would greatly appreciate it. I've included my updated version of this workbook below. Again, the User form in question is the "Penn Shoulder" and the button that will execute the CountIf statement could the the "PennShoulderCalculateButton" button.

And of course, thank you for the suggestions thus far.