Fill cells in one sheet one column with values from other spreadsheets matching 2 criteria

for forum 5 rev.xlsxSpreadsheet "Elem FCAT Reading" needs column E filled with score from "2012 R3 sch" column m, if/where columns B & D match.
Spreadsheet "Elem FCAT Reading" needs column F filled with score from "2013 R3 sch" column m, if/where columns B & D match.
...etc.
("Elem FCAT Reading" needs columns E, F, H, I, K, L, filled from other spreadsheets, column m, if/where columns B & D match.)
attached sample but not all spreadsheets are there, too big.


Tried lookup but can't workaround two criteria and do not know index and match well enough to generate syntax...any help greatly appreciated!!
Thanks,
Synthia