If statement won't recognize two values as equal

Hi all,

I've included a detailed screen shot with some notes on it, I would encourage taking a look at that.
The issue I'm having is that a loop statement of mine is failing to recognize that a couple values are equal. It works for the first 3 iterations of the loop, then stops recognizing. I tried copying another set of numbers in the failing one's place, and that actually worked.
Not sure how else to explain it, but if you take a look at the screen shot you can see the excel sheet being worked on and the vba code running. I will also include a text file of the code for anyone who would like to change the code to offer a suggestion.

Thank you!