Let me rephrase, so maybe someone can steer me in the right direction:

When I RECORD the creation of a pivot table, and I select columns A-D as my source, the code recorded for that selection is: 
"'Summary View'!C1:C4"
When I PLAY BACK the macro, "'Summary View'!C1:C4" is interpreted as Column C, rows 1-4.

That's a problem for me, and I don't know how to overcome it.