IF Statement with VLOOKUP

[berger01]

I am trying to have VLOOKUP function only IF a cell is populated with any of 3 values. I'm using IF(OR(.... but that might not be the way to go. Any help would be great:

I also am adding 1 to the value returned from VLOOKUP:

=IF(OR(P2="1",P2="2",P2="3"),IF(ISNA(VLOOKUP(D2,QTR1_2011,14,FALSE)),"",(VLOOKUP(D2,QTR1_2011,14,FALSE)+1)))

Thanks to all you Experts.