How do I paste special values with Destination:=Worksheets

I'm running the following code:

                     If .Range("E" & RowCount) = CatArray(CatArr) Then
                        .Range("D" & RowCount).Copy
                        .Paste Destination:=Worksheets _
                        (MonthArray(MonthArr)).Cells _
                        ((RowCount + 19 + CatArr), (Day + 3))
                     End If

Which works fine. But I want to paste special values except when I try this:

                     If .Range("E" & RowCount) = CatArray(CatArr) Then
                        .Range("D" & RowCount).Copy
                        .PasteSpecial xlPasteValues Destination:=Worksheets _
                        (MonthArray(MonthArr)).Cells _
                        ((RowCount + 19 + CatArr), (Day + 3))
                     End If

I'm getting a syntax error. How do I make this work?