Ranking by certain criteria

In my worksheet I have a tie for high score and use a tie breaker to determine winner. Tie breaker is number closest to another number (higher or lower ) . However, If the Tie breaker is 36 and exactly in between the high scorers tie breaker (33 and 39) I want the lower tie breaker to be the winner. In my formula, if the number falls exactly in between it will rank the tied high scorers by alphabetical order of player name. Attached is small file to show what i have..... my formula is in my tie breaker helper column "F3"

I would appreciate any help..