Should be Column A then D then C. You entered C, D, A

CTRL + SHIFT + ENTER

=INDEX(PhysMaster!$A$2:$A$841,MATCH(F9&H9&G9,PhysMaster!$A$2:$A$841&PhysMaster!$D$2:$D$841&PhysMaster!$C$2:$C$841,0))