That being the case it would appear that instead of changing the values in column A of table 5 from A,B,C... to 1,2,3... (as in the file attached to post #22) they instead need to be changed them from A,B,C... to 5,4,3... Making that change yields the values stated in post #23
Let me know if you if you need to see my updated copy of the file.
Bookmarks