From Excel working to Google Sheets no longer working

My formula worked until recently in Google Sheets, what gives?

=vlookup($E2,Players!$A$2:$P$489,5,false)

I attached the spreadsheet that works in excel. Maybe some expert can tell me how to make this work in Google Sheets?!

On the highlights tab, I put in the ID and the players name populates, as well as the division (A,B,C or D)

thanks,
rad1964