INDEX MATCH with multiple same dates

Hey Exelonauts,

I thought I was done with this spreadsheet, but it went live today and Im having a small issue. On the Dartmouth, Sydney, Bridgewater, and Digby tabs I want to track all of the transfers that happen on the Pronto Tab, however it seems that if its on the same date it just uses the newest entry all the way down when I try to select either the whole column, or just B2:B4000. But on a different workbook this formula works correctly in giving the answers in order of newest enteries. For Dartmouth I need it to look like this under 13W CFL 96,288,0,336,0. But when I change the formula to look at the whole colomn it returns 96 all the way down. What am I missing?

Thanks