Sorry Sinhus,

yes you have gave me the solution,
I just didn't put it correct the first time so didn't get it to work
as I never changed the first cell number (what a donut I am) its been one of them days up to now but hopefully it will now get better lol

Thank you thank you thank you very much

And thanks to you as well Dave H for spelling it out for me in the sheet

much appreciation to both of you

thank you

Gordon