VLOOKUP returning the wrong value

[ortmll]

I am trying to us a VLOOKUP formula to indicate a daily FTE value based upon the hours an employee works.
I am calculating the hours in column C and using the VLOOKUP in column D. I've ensured that the hours data is formatted the same way.
However, the value it returns is not matching up with the hours in the table.

I am quite frustrated. Any input would be welcome.
Thank you!
Time_Calc_image.jpg