Lookups

Starguy, you were helping me with an issue I had the other day and I have a small issue. You mentioned that the helper columns weren't required, but my question is...would you use them or would you use the second suggestion you made.

My problem is that when I am searching for a value instead of text....the value appears and adds 1 to it, therefore putting a numeric value higher than 1 for the first occurance.

File is attached, please not Column B, which is searching column S for instances of "60". When it finds the value, it adds 1 to it, placing 61 in the cell. Well, when I am referencing this on the Formations page, it won't show up b/c it is looking for 1 (not 61). Any help?