Vlookup for multiple criteria using multiple table arrays

I have a Vlookup that works great - But I am trying to implement some changes to auto select or formula that knows which array to use, as opposed to using the same range since it changes with date.

Attached is a sample data file with the Headers: Pricing Date, Year, Benchmark, YLD, SPRD

The lookup is pulling the benchmark number from the "Selected Bench" Tab. Is there a way to adjust the formula to pull from a different array depending on whatever the pricing date may be?

Any help would be appreciated, Thanks