Still not sure what we are doing.
So you have 2 sets of data.
Here's what I think you are asking for.
First, the first columns need to match (that gets rid of "Rick")
Then check the second column.
The only one that matches in Col 2 is "Example" so that value (a "Y") gets put into the new cell (Like IceStation did)
Then, we move to the next col (3).
Do you want to only look in 3 if it matched in 2 or look at all of them?