Hi all,
I am trying to include Wingdings symbols in formulas..
Some VBA cater for ticks and X
Would appreciate a formula fix to include Symbols please.
The attached WB provides example and outcome
Hi all,
I am trying to include Wingdings symbols in formulas..
Some VBA cater for ticks and X
Would appreciate a formula fix to include Symbols please.
The attached WB provides example and outcome
Last edited by VisionSmart; 02-11-2020 at 03:42 AM.
Administrative note
Welcome to the forum
in your haste to solve your problem, you probably missed the yellow banner advising how to get answers faster by posting a sheet ?
Please take a moment to read it and attach a sheet accordingly.
Thanks you for helping us help you
Is it this you are looking for?
![]()
Please Login or Register to view this content.
Thankyou Haluk. That formula produces 'FALSE" in cell H10.
There is a typo in the formula, while converting to your language settings....
Change ; to , in the formula
.
Thankyou
I believe I fixed that typo. Now, the X records the correct 2.5, but neither of the Tick cell (B10 and C10 do not produce any result in H10.
See attached.
Sorry but, I don't understand what you are trying to calculate with the formula .....
.
If a Tick appears in B10, then H10 will present 1. If a tick appears in C10, H10 will present 2. If X presents in D10, H10 will display 2.5
If multiple selections, (say a tick in B10 and C10, or a Tick in C10 an X in D10), then H10 remains blank.
Can you check the attached file?
.
All Good now Thankyou Haluk
Further to WB Ver D, have been working on the missing parts of the formulae for K10.
Attached is WB ‘Formulae with Symbols-D4’ which contains additional Tab - Sheet1 (4) with following amendments:
No VBA;
Created Named Ranges Expectations__√ and Expectations_X - used in E10, F10, G10 as applicable;
Changed cells in row I24: AF24 to √, √, X (Calibri font);
Changed formulae in K10 to include Match functions for E10,F10,G10;
But I get error “You’ve entered too many arguments etc.and I cannot locate that error.
Hope someone can assist with a fix please.
Last edited by VisionSmart; 02-18-2020 at 03:35 AM. Reason: Additional Information and Another Tab added
This Thread started out as using Wingdings , but have now realised not needed?
Further to previous attempts, attached is new WB ‘Formulae for Symbols-C’. which contains modified formulae in K10, which does not work, but may be closer to a solution using multiple MATCH Function.
Referring to attached, Separate dissections - cell E12, works OK.
But dissection in cell F12, and G12 do not work
Require correct Formula in K10 to cater for all combinations in the Matrix Table i24 : AF29 - based on one selection in A10, C10, and E10, or F10, or G10.
May require a totally different approach to this one?
Some changes to the WB - so Ver D is attached.
Hoping someone can solve this one please
Hello all
Reviewed all formulae and found some errors which are now corrected in attached WB - Formulae for Symbols-E.
Also added some additional comments to help understand the issue.
Hoping for a solution please.
See if this works for you in F12:
=INDEX($I$26:$AF$29,MATCH(C10,$G$26:$G$29,0),MATCH(F9&A10&F10,$I$23:$AF$23&$I$24:$AF$24&$I$25:$AF$25,0))
Or in E12 copied across:
=INDEX($I$26:$AF$29,MATCH($C$10,$G$26:$G$29,0),MATCH(F$9&$A$10&F$10,$I$23:$AF$23&$I$24:$AF$24&$I$25:$AF$25,0))
The lookup references could, of course, be drop-down boxes.
By the way:
Excel 2016 (Windows) 32 bit
G H 10 XThis formula in K10 does not work >>> 11 12 0.75 13 14 No 15 Result 16with X 17 F10 should 18 be 9.75WRONG! See N29 … 19 as per 20 N29 21
Sheet: Sheet1
Last edited by AliGW; 04-25-2020 at 06:20 AM.
Ali
Enthusiastic self-taught user of MS Excel who's always learning!
Don't forget to say "thank you" in your thread to anyone who has offered you help. It's a universal courtesy.
You can reward them by clicking on * Add Reputation below their user name on the left, if you wish.
NB: as a Moderator, I never accept friendship requests.
Forum Rules (updated August 2023): please read them here.
Thank you Teacher. My apologies re the typo.
Your suggested formulae in E12, F12, G12 all present #VALUE! with or without a selection in Row 10. See attached Ver E1
The aim is to have one formula in K10.
When the dissected formulae are correct, how do I build the one formula in K10?
The references are incorrect. In E12 you need this:
=INDEX($I$26:$AF$29,MATCH($C$10,$G$26:$G$29,0),MATCH(E$9&$A$10&E$10,$I$23:$AF$23&$I$24:$AF$24&$I$25:$AF$25,0))
Excel 2016 (Windows) 32 bit
E 10 v 11 12 1.25 13 14 Works 15 OK 16 eith 17 Tick v 18 in E10 19 matches 20 L29 21
Sheet: Sheet1
Now, explain how you expect this to work, particularly the bit in red:
Why B10? There is nothing there. And how is the formula meant to decide between E10, F10 and G10. There's something missing from your requirements - the missing link is what I need, although I suspect the formula I've given you will do what you need if you have drop-downs in certain cells.Expected Outcome in K10 should be a value from below matrix, depending on selection in A10, B10, and one of E10, F10 or G10.
Last edited by AliGW; 04-25-2020 at 07:36 AM.
OK - I think this might be what you are after in K10:
=IF(COUNTIF($E$10:$G$10,"<>")=1,INDEX($I$26:$AF$29,MATCH($C$10,$G$26:$G$29,0),MATCH(LOOKUP(2,1/($E$10:$G$10<>""),$E$9:$G$9)&$A$10&LOOKUP("zzzzzzzzzzzz",$E$10:$G$10),$I$23:$AF$23&$I$24:$AF$24&$I$25:$AF$25,0)),"")
If not, then you really will need to explain in more detail what you are trying to achieve.
We are getting there AliGW.
Your formula in E12 still does not work for me. - see attached Rev E2
I don't understand what E$9 (your formula) relates to.
My mistake again in the line at J17 - line - should read C10
Expected Outcome in K10 should be a value from below matrix, depending on selection in A10, C10, and one of E10, F10 or G10.
There are Named Ranges and dropdowns for all selection cells in Row 10.
So, selection from Dropdown in A10
Then selection from Dropdown in C10.
Then select one of E10, F10, or G10 - only one of the "group" E10:G10
Those three selections should produce an answer in K10.
All named ranges include a blank to easily clear the cell/s.
Did you see post #18?
You may need to enter the formula as an array formula if you are still using Excel 2010 (by using CTRL+SHIFT+ENTER instead of just ENTER).
Last edited by AliGW; 04-25-2020 at 08:15 AM.
May be a cross-over here.
Fantastic formulae AliGW. Glad you are a Maths expert!
Your formulae in K10 displays blank result (See Red border) in attached Rev E3.
Yes, that is correct. There is nothing selected in the range E10 to G10 - until one of those cells is populated, the formula will not kick in:
Excel 2016 (Windows) 32 bit
E F G 10
Sheet: Sheet1
You said that one of those cells needed to be populated, and with blanks, there will be no match, anyway.
Look at the first section of my formula:
=IF(COUNTIF($E$10:$G$10,"<>")=1, ...
This is nothing to do with maths, by the way. It's not even to do with symbols. It's just logic.
AliGW
All good now thank you!!. Your returned WB works great.
I will need to study the various parts to try to understand better.
I will close this one off.
Stay safe, healthy etc. till we meet again sometime.
No worries! Please mark the thread as solved.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Bookmarks